The Hokuriku Shinkansen's Ultimate Solution? A Railway Journalist's "Ultra C" Proposal Beyond Maibara and Kyoto

Photo by T Leish on Pexels

For railway enthusiasts like myself, the very mention of the Shinkansen conjures images of sleek silver and white streaks, gracefully gliding through landscapes, connecting distant cities with breathtaking speed and efficiency. It’s more than just transport; it’s a symbol of human ingenuity, engineering prowess, and the romance of travel. Today, we’re diving into one of the most exciting and hotly debated topics in Japanese railway circles: the completion of the Hokuriku Shinkansen, and a revolutionary proposal that promises to break a long-standing deadlock.

The Dream of a Fully Connected Hokuriku Shinkansen

The Hokuriku Shinkansen, already an engineering marvel linking Tokyo to Kanazawa and beyond, is a vital artery for Japan's Hokuriku region. Its extension to Tsuruga is eagerly anticipated, yet the final segment connecting Tsuruga to Shin-Osaka remains a subject of intense discussion. This last leg is crucial for truly integrating the Hokuriku region into the broader national Shinkansen network, unlocking immense potential for tourism, business, and local communities. However, two primary routes have dominated the conversation, each with its own set of challenges and advocates, leading to a prolonged stalemate.

The Stalemate: Maibara vs. Kyoto

For years, the debate has largely centered around two main contenders for the final route: the Maibara Route and the Kyoto Route. Each offers distinct advantages and disadvantages:

• The Maibara Route: This option would connect the Hokuriku Shinkansen to the existing Tokaido Shinkansen at Maibara Station. Proponents often highlight its potential cost-effectiveness due to utilizing existing infrastructure and easing transfers for passengers heading towards Nagoya and beyond. However, critics worry about potential congestion on the already busy Tokaido Shinkansen line and the need for passengers to transfer at Maibara, which could be seen as less convenient for direct access to major urban centers further west.
• The Kyoto Route: Advocated by many as a direct link to one of Japan’s most iconic tourist destinations, Kyoto, this route would bring the Hokuriku Shinkansen directly into the heart of the ancient capital. This would undoubtedly boost tourism to the Hokuriku region and offer seamless connections for international visitors. Yet, the challenges are formidable, involving complex urban tunneling through a densely populated and historically significant city, potentially leading to higher construction costs and environmental concerns.

The impasse has been frustrating for many, as the dream of a fully completed Hokuriku Shinkansen hangs in the balance, waiting for a definitive path forward.

Enter the "Ultra C": An Ingenious Alternative

This is where the excitement truly begins! A prominent railway journalist has stepped forward with an innovative proposal, a truly extraordinary solution that is neither the Maibara Route nor the Kyoto Route. This bold vision has been dubbed an "Ultra C" – a term borrowed from gymnastics, signifying an exceptionally difficult and ingenious maneuver that dramatically changes the game. This proposal, gaining significant attention and highlighted as one of the "BEST" discussions in September 2025, offers a tantalizing glimpse into a future where the deadlock is finally broken.

While the specific details of this "Ultra C" route remain a subject of ongoing expert discussion, its very existence speaks volumes about the enduring spirit of innovation in Japanese railway engineering. It suggests a path that could potentially mitigate the drawbacks of both conventional options, perhaps by finding a less congested corridor, a more cost-effective alignment, or a route that unlocks new development opportunities for overlooked regions. Imagine a route that weaves through lesser-known but equally beautiful landscapes, showcasing a different facet of Japan's natural splendor!

The Romance of Rails: Design, History, Scenery, and Technology

Such an "Ultra C" proposal isn't just about lines on a map; it's about the very soul of railway travel. It embodies the passion that drives us to build and explore:

• Vehicle Design: Any new Shinkansen route would undoubtedly be graced by the latest generation of trains, perhaps building upon the elegant and powerful E7/W7 series currently operating on the Hokuriku line. Their sleek aerodynamics, quiet interiors, and advanced safety features are a testament to Japan's relentless pursuit of perfection in train design, offering an unparalleled travel experience.
• History of the Lines: Every new Shinkansen segment adds another chapter to Japan's illustrious railway history, a history marked by ambition, overcoming challenging terrain, and connecting people. This "Ultra C" could become another legendary feat, celebrated for its ingenuity in bypassing existing complexities.
• Scenery Along the Lines: Imagine the new vistas! While the specifics are yet to be unveiled, a route avoiding dense urban areas might offer passengers breathtaking views of Japan's rural heartland, majestic mountains, serene rivers, or even glimpses of the Sea of Japan. The Shinkansen isn't just a means to an end; it's a moving viewpoint, revealing the ever-changing beauty of the country.
• Innovative Technology: Building a Shinkansen line, especially one tackling an "Ultra C" challenge, requires cutting-edge technology in tunneling, bridge construction, seismic resistance, and operational control. This proposal is a call to push the boundaries of engineering once again, ensuring safety, speed, and environmental harmony.

This "Ultra C" isn't merely a pragmatic solution; it's a testament to the visionaries who see beyond the immediate obstacles, daring to dream of a more connected and efficient Japan. It reignites the imagination, reminding us that the spirit of innovation that gave birth to the Shinkansen system is still very much alive.

The Future Awaits

The proposed "Ultra C" route for the Hokuriku Shinkansen is more than just a potential path; it's a beacon of hope for resolving a critical infrastructure challenge. It exemplifies how thoughtful, out-of-the-box thinking from a dedicated railway journalist can inject new energy into complex discussions. The completion of this vital line will not only enhance regional connectivity but will also strengthen Japan's entire railway network, inviting travelers from around the world to experience the unparalleled joy and efficiency of its trains.

As we anticipate further details of this extraordinary proposal, let us celebrate the enduring romance of railways – a romance that continues to inspire engineers, travelers, and dreamers alike to look beyond the horizon. Perhaps, very soon, we will be boarding a train on the fully completed Hokuriku Shinkansen, marveling at the scenery, and appreciating the "Ultra C" ingenuity that made it all possible. All aboard for the future!